Is Juice Kid-Friendly? Shocking Sugar Facts About Juice

When I was growing up, “juice” was standard fare for kids. Those were the Kool-Aid days…. But now we realize that even juice that comes from real fruits and not a packet of sugary powder is not necessarily healthful.

What is so wrong about juice or other sugary beverages? Isn’t a glass of orange juice an important part of a well-rounded breakfast?

Here are some facts about juice and sugary beverages that may surprise you.

One cup (8 ounces) of apple juice–even 100% apple juice with no sugar added–has the same amount of sugar as 5 apples. Five! Can you imagine your child eating 5 apples at once? The same approximation is true for orange juice. And many companies sell juices in much larger quantities: an average bottle is 15.2 ounces: that’s nearly 10 apples worth of sugar.

We all know that soda is bad for us. But did you know that juice and soda have a similar sugar content? A 12 ounce can of coke, for example, has 40 grams of sugar. ( 4 grams of sugar are equivalent to 1 teaspoon and so that is nearly 10 teaspoons of sugar.) The average bottle of apple juice? Though sugar content varies, most apple juice has about 40 g of sugar in a 12 oz bottle. Again, that’s equivalent to almost 10 teaspoons of sugar.

And the sugar in juice packs a punch. When kids eat an apple, the fiber in the apple slows the processing of the sugar, allowing it to enter the blood stream at a slow, steady rate.  Juice lacks this fiber, however, and the sugar gets absorbed and metabolized rapidly, like jet engine fuel, pushing your child up into the stratosphere, only to come crashing down.   What does science have to say about the impact of sugary beverages on kids’ health?  

These days, we all know that obesity is an epidemic.  Studies looking at the role of sugary beverages in the development of obesity suggest an association.  And can we prevent this?  A recent study suggested that putting drinking fountains in schools decreased obesity. Did the kids in the schools with drinking fountains drink more water and therefore fewer sugary beverages? While the causation was not straightforward, it is certainly suggestive. 
A study published in the April 2009 Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine found that sugary beverage consumption correlates to insulin resistance in adolescents. Insulin resistance leads to type 2 diabetes, which is on the rise in adolescents and children. In other words, research suggests that drinking too much juice, soda and other sugary beverages may contribute to the development of diabetes.

In the end, juice is not poison.  And it is not the only factor leading to childhood obesity and diabetes in modern society.  But for children, juice is not an elixir of health, and should not be treated as such.
So what to do? Cut out the juice, or at least minimize juice consumption. Stick to water. Water is, after all, the elixir of life…. 

Tips for parents:

  • I recommend that kids of all ages drink mostly water and milk.
  • I advise parents to think of juice as “liquid candy.” Okay, perhaps that is a little dramatic, but for a healthy diet juice should be considered a treat rather than a routine addition to a meal or a means of hydration.
  • If you do give your child juice, take a lesson from the French:  they serve it in the cutest itty-bitty glasses.
  • To make sure that your child gets all of the vitamins and minerals that they need to stay healthy, encourage them to eat plenty of whole fruits and vegetables. Your child will get plenty of vitamins eating an orange instead of drinking a glass of orange juice, without the excess of sugar or the spike and fall in blood glucose.



add to :: Add to Blinkslist :: add to furl :: Digg it :: add to ma.gnolia :: Stumble It! :: add to simpy :: seed the vine :: :: :: TailRank :: post to facebook



Filed under Healthy Eating, Toddlers

4 responses to “Is Juice Kid-Friendly? Shocking Sugar Facts About Juice

  1. Bryan

    I am surprised you don’t advocate putting two thirds or half water in a sippy cup with juice.

    • knewell72

      Thanks for the thought Bryan. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommendations state: “Intake of fruit juice should be limited to 4 to 6 oz/d for children 1 to 6 years old. For children 7 to 18 years old, juice intake should be limited to 8 to 12 oz or 2 servings per day. ”

      As for me, I’d still rather them eat whole fruit and drink water!

  2. Wonderful information! We are not juice drinkers in our house, therefore our 2 year old does not have juice as an option. Choices are milk or water.

    However, she will be starting back a Mom’s Morning Out program at church, and they serve juice with snack. Last year, I asked the teachers to give her water. But many times, especially near the end of the year, she received juice. (I know because she had some left in her cup when we got to the car.)

    I really do not want her to have juice often. Would it be over-zealous on my part if I stress to the teachers to only give her water? She (so far) does not throw a fit when she sees someone with a different drink than she has, so I don’t see that being a problem.

    How adamant should I be?

    • knewell72

      Hi Heather,
      Thanks for the comment. It is very hard for parents who would like to avoid juice when many institutions still consider juice the routine drink for kids. I think that helping to advocate for decreased use of juice in schools and other programs will be helpful for not only your own child but also for her peers! And as long as she doesn’t protest too much, I don’t think your current plan is doing any disservice.
      Excellent work!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s